Vikings Message Board.Com

CharVike wrote: ↑Sun Aug 24, 2025 11:14 am I think this is a good move. Obviously they like him better than what they have.

VikingsFan12345 wrote: ↑Sun Aug 24, 2025 3:02 pm

CharVike wrote: ↑Sun Aug 24, 2025 11:14 am I think this is a good move. Obviously they like him better than what they have.

Ehh, Carson has never been the same since his knee injury

VikingLord wrote: ↑Mon Aug 25, 2025 4:35 pm I see there are three threads on the QBs, so I'm going to just respond on this one since it deals with the latest addition.

I'm a little surprised that the Vikings gave up on Sam Howell so quickly. Yes, he looked terrible in the 2nd preseason game and I don't know what he was like in the locker room or off the field, but they did give up a 5th round pick to obtain him and one would hope they did their homework before making that move. Howell wasn't really all that different than Sam Darnold in terms of a reclamation project, so he must have really underwhelmed to get shipped so quickly.

As for Carson Wentz, he can't be worse than Howell but I don't think he can be better than Darnold. He's the definition of the vet journeyman. Worst-case scenario he ends up doing what Jim McMahon did for the Vikings in the early 90's. Hopefully it won't come to that and McCarthy will play the entire season.

As for Rypien, I was surprised he didn't do more with his opportunity. I think he's got more talent than he showed in his preseason action where he looked unsure and ineffective for the most part.

And lastly, Max Brosmer... What can be said about him? He looked fantastic when he was on the field. He looked calm and in command, decisive and accurate. Not flawless, but if someone told me he was undrafted I would have thought they were joking. I understand why the Vikings want a veteran QB on the roster and I understand Brosmer hasn't done anything yet in real game situations that could shed more light on how good he really is, but if McCarthy were to get hurt and KOC decided to trot Brosmer out to take his place behind center, I wouldn't be upset.

But here's hoping for health at the offensive skill positions and along the line this year. McCarthy will get his chance to show what he can do.

Cliff wrote: ↑Mon Aug 25, 2025 8:02 pm They didn't give up a 5th for him, they just moved down in the round. As far as draft capital they actually did quite well moving him. I'm glad they had it in them to just call a spade a spade and move on.

Max Brosmer earned his spot for sure. If McCarthy goes down I'd actually prefer for him to play and see what the Vikings have in him.

Cliff wrote: ↑Mon Aug 25, 2025 8:02 pm

VikingLord wrote: ↑Mon Aug 25, 2025 4:35 pm I see there are three threads on the QBs, so I'm going to just respond on this one since it deals with the latest addition.

I'm a little surprised that the Vikings gave up on Sam Howell so quickly. Yes, he looked terrible in the 2nd preseason game and I don't know what he was like in the locker room or off the field, but they did give up a 5th round pick to obtain him and one would hope they did their homework before making that move. Howell wasn't really all that different than Sam Darnold in terms of a reclamation project, so he must have really underwhelmed to get shipped so quickly.

As for Carson Wentz, he can't be worse than Howell but I don't think he can be better than Darnold. He's the definition of the vet journeyman. Worst-case scenario he ends up doing what Jim McMahon did for the Vikings in the early 90's. Hopefully it won't come to that and McCarthy will play the entire season.

As for Rypien, I was surprised he didn't do more with his opportunity. I think he's got more talent than he showed in his preseason action where he looked unsure and ineffective for the most part.

And lastly, Max Brosmer... What can be said about him? He looked fantastic when he was on the field. He looked calm and in command, decisive and accurate. Not flawless, but if someone told me he was undrafted I would have thought they were joking. I understand why the Vikings want a veteran QB on the roster and I understand Brosmer hasn't done anything yet in real game situations that could shed more light on how good he really is, but if McCarthy were to get hurt and KOC decided to trot Brosmer out to take his place behind center, I wouldn't be upset.

But here's hoping for health at the offensive skill positions and along the line this year. McCarthy will get his chance to show what he can do.

They didn't give up a 5th for him, they just moved down in the round. As far as draft capital they actually did quite well moving him. I'm glad they had it in them to just call a spade a spade and move on.

Max Brosmer earned his spot for sure. If McCarthy goes down I'd actually prefer for him to play and see what the Vikings have in him.

VikingsVictorious wrote: ↑Sat Aug 30, 2025 8:44 am

Cliff wrote: ↑Mon Aug 25, 2025 8:02 pm

They didn't give up a 5th for him, they just moved down in the round. As far as draft capital they actually did quite well moving him. I'm glad they had it in them to just call a spade a spade and move on.

Max Brosmer earned his spot for sure. If McCarthy goes down I'd actually prefer for him to play and see what the Vikings have in him.

Bros B4 Hoesmer may have "looked" good in preseason, but he only completed 60% of his attempts at 6.3 yards per attempt. I'm completely underwhelmed by him. Easy choice to go with Wentz over him.